| 1993 | Kendall | Dillon | Poteau | OK | 2nd Team |
| 1993 | Marlin | Johnson | Hooks | TX | 2nd Team |
| 1994 | Ronnie | Sockey | Pocola | OK | 1st Team |
| 1995 | Justin | Crase | Wister | OK | 1st Team |
| 1996 | Shane | Wooten | Wister | OK | 1st Team |
| 1996 | Brian | Stout | Catoosa | OK | 3rd Team |
| 1997 | Aaron | Thompson | Calera | OK | 2nd Team |
| 1999 | Kevin | Ferguson | Broken Arrow | OK | 2nd Team |
| 1999 | Steven | Rubert | Tulsa | OK | 3rd Team |
| 2000 | Chad | Fox | Cameron | OK | 1st Team |
| 2001 | Chad | Fox | Cameron | OK | 1st Team |
| 2001 | Brandon | Raines | Cameron | OK | 3rd Team |
| 2002 | Brandon | Raines | Cameron | OK | 1st Team |
| 2007 | Ryan | Bowen | Cameron | OK | 2nd Team |
| 2012 | Matt | Johnson | Asher | OK | 2nd Team |
| NJCAA Gold Glove | |||||
| 2012 | Dwight | Camp | Red Oak | OK | |
| 2017 | Will | Klek | Ft. Smith | AR | OF |
| 2018 | Ben | Klutts | Poteau | OK | 3B |
| 2019 | Morgan | Crenshaw | Red Oak | OK | SS |
| 2019 | Ben | Klutts | PoteaU | OK | 3B |
| NJCAA Academic All-American Team (HM) | |||||
| 2018, 3.08 GPA | |||||
| 2020, 3.05 GPA | |||||
| NJCAA Academic All-Americans | |||||
| 1994 | Steven | Kendrick | Indianola, | OK | |
| 1997 | Wes | McGowen | Fanshawe, | OK | |
| 1998 | Nathan | Dickinson | Sailisaw, | OK | |
| 1999 | Tyson | Trent | Rattan, | OK | |
| 1999 | Les | Pratt | Sailisaw, | OK | |
| 2002 | Jon | Humphers | Stonewall, | OK | |
| 2003 | Jay | Fox | Preston, | OK | |
| 2003 | Zac | Tiger | Dewar, | OK | |
| 2003 | Ryan | Lane | Weleetka, | OK | |
| 2006 | Cory | Allison | Greenwood, | AR | |
| 2006 | Mark | Leon | Greenwood, | AR | |
| 2006 | Mitch | Worley | Roff, | OK | |
| 2008 | Chad | Anglin | Moore, | OK | |
| 2009 | John | Homer | McAlester, | OK | |
| 2009 | Anthony | Acker | Coalgate, | OK | |
| 2011 | Kelby | Wendt | Mangum | OK | 3rd Team, Exemplary |
| 2013 | Brian | Holt | Sentinel | OK | 3rd Team, Exemplary |
| 2014 | Cody | Luman | Wister | OK | 3rd Team, Exemplary |
| 2014 | Carter | Cumbie | McAlester | OK | 3rd Team, Exemplary |
| 2016 | Trevor | Hudgens | Dewey | OK | 2nd Team, Superior |
| 2017 | Brandon | Girabaldie | International | 2nd Team | |
| 2017 | Dylan | Thurber | Vian | OK | 2nd Team |
| 2017 | Joshua | Cowart | Vian | OK | 2nd Team |
| 2017 | Preston | Whitten | Wagoner | OK | 2nd Team |
| 2018 | Ben | Klutts | Poteau | OK | 2nd Team |
| 2020 | Justice | Hayes | Arlingotn | TX | 2nd Team |
| 2020 | Dylan | Clark | Denton | TX | 2nd Team |
| 2020 | Daven | Blanco | Denver City | TX | 2nd Team |
| 2020 | John | Turbeville | El Dorado | AR | 3rd Team |
| NJCAA Academic All-Americans | |||||
| 1996 | Jeff | Nolan | Heavener, | OK | 1st Team, Pinnacle |
| 1998 | Kit | Claborn | Wright City, | OK | 1st Team, Pinnacle |
| 2000 | James | Remington | Okmulgee, | OK | 1st Team, Pinnacle |
| 2001 | Matt | Fowler | Dewar, | OK | 1st Team, Pinnacle |
| 2004 | Jason | Greenfield | Chickasha, | OK | 1st Team, Pinnacle |
| 2005 | Ryan | Gibbs | Madill, | OK | 1st Team, Pinnacle |
| 2005 | Jason | Hill | Kellyvilie, | OK | 1st Team, Pinnacle |
| 2005 | Brooks | Pollard | Poteau, | OK | 1st Team, Pinnacle |
| 2006 | Bryan | Nichols | Cordell, | OK | 1st Team, Pinnacle |
| 2006 | Brooks | Pollard | Pate, | OK | 1st Team, Pinnacle |
| 2012 | Austin | Phippen | Cashion, | OK | 1st Team, Pinnacle |
| 2013 | Austin | Phippen | Cashion, | OK | 1st Team, Pinnacle |